Elizabeth Johnson was found guilty of custodial interference and conspiracy in the December 2009 disappearance of baby Gabriel Johnson.
PHOENIX (CBS5) -
The jury has found Elizabeth Johnson guilty of conspiracy to commit custodial interference, custodial interference and unlawful imprisonment in the disappearance of her son Gabriel.
Jurors couldn't reach a verdict on the most serious charge, kidnapping.
"We are obviously thrilled with what the jury did today. It was really the primary effort of our case was to go after the kidnapping charge, that was the focus of exactly what we were doing," Elizabeth Johnson's attorney Marc Victor told CBS 5 News. "Our entire defense was based on the kidnapping charge. And the jury saw it our way."
They deliberated for about a day and a half.
Elizabeth Johnson is the Valley mother who ran off to San Antonio, TX, with her 8-month-old son Gabriel Johnson in December 2009. He has not been seen since.
Attorneys wrapped up their closing arguments on Tuesday and the jury began deliberation on Wednesday morning.
Prosecutors told jurors that Elizabeth Johnson was angry and determined to "get back" at the child's father, Logan McQueary. The couple had recently broken up and McQueary was granted joint custody.
Prosecutors said that Elizabeth Johnson wanted to give the child up for adoption, but when McQueary refused, Elizabeth Johnson took the child to Texas without McQueary's permission.
"She wants to get back at Logan, and she is upset, and she uses the one thing that would hurt Logan more than anything," prosecutor Angela Andrews said.
After the verdict was read, McQueary's father spoke with CBS 5 News.
"If you think about it from the jury's perspective, let's not anybody think bad about them. They found her guilty of everything. They just didn't find her guilty of what, to us, was the most important thing, because it gave her the most prison time."
Victor did not present any evidence during the trial or call any witnesses.
He told the jury that prosecutors failed to prove their case that Elizabeth Johnson kidnapped her son.
Victor admitted that his client was guilty of custodial interference, but said that Elizabeth Johnson had every right to leave the state with her son at the time that she did.
"This is not a case about whether or not you like Elizabeth Johnson," said Victor. "This was not a kidnapping."
Judge Joseph Kreamer on Tuesday denied a defense motion to drop the kidnapping charge against Elizabeth Johnson.
Victor said in his motion that Arizona does not have the jurisdiction to prosecute Elizabeth Johnson for kidnapping. [Read full motion (PDF)]
Victor's motion states Elizabeth Johnson legally traveled to Texas with her son and every element the state presented in the kidnapping case would have occurred in Texas, outside the jurisdiction of Arizona.
Tuesday, March 11 2014 7:46 AM EDT2014-03-11 11:46:38 GMT
WILMINGTON, NC (WECT) – No charges will be filed against the people responsible for hanging a dog by a harness at Olga's Dog Spa. A photograph began circulating around social media last week of a dogMore >
No charges will be filed against the people responsible for hanging a dog by a harness at Olga's Dog Spa.More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 6:04 PM EDT2014-03-11 22:04:32 GMT
Police identified the two women found dead in a running motor vehicle in Lebanon Monday morning. Troopers were called to Smith Road near Route 207 around 8:50 a.m. after a person reported seeing two peopleMore >
Police identified the couple found dead in a running motor vehicle in Lebanon Monday morning.More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 7:05 PM EDT2014-03-11 23:05:09 GMT
Firefighters in West Haven are on the scene of an early morning fire. Officials said the fire was called in at 89 Coleman Street shortly after 4:30 a.m. There is no word on if anyone has been injured. WFSBMore >
Officials said a couple and their grown daughter were killed in an early morning fire Tuesday at a West Haven condominium complex.More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 1:30 PM EDT2014-03-11 17:30:08 GMT
Three Connecticut towns made the list of the best places to visit in New England. Guilford, Washington and Wethersfield were listed on Buzz Feed's 24 Small New England Towns You Absolutely Need To Visit.GuilfordMore >
Three Connecticut towns made the list of the best places to visit in New England. More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 8:28 AM EDT2014-03-11 12:28:24 GMT
A Hartford police sergeant was in the hot seat following a high speed chase that was caught on camera. A few weeks ago, Sgt. Eric Smith barreled through a red light on a city street, hit speeds of 80 milesMore >
A Hartford police sergeant was in the hot seat following a high speed chase that was caught on camera.More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 12:18 PM EDT2014-03-11 16:18:44 GMT
Hundreds of tickets have been handed out by state police since they started targeting tailgating motorists on highways in an effort to reduce accidents and what they call "aggressive driving habits."TheMore >
Hundreds of tickets have been handed out by state police since they started targeting tailgating motorists on highways in an effort to reduce accidents and what they call "aggressive driving habits."More >
Tuesday, March 11 2014 4:13 PM EDT2014-03-11 20:13:53 GMT
Customers with Verizon Wireless have been the target of scammers, officials said.The scammers were promising people $54 dollars based on an overpaid bill. They even make it look like it's coming from Verizon'sMore >
Customers with Verizon Wireless have been the target of scammers, officials said.More >